Defined by creativity or consumption?
What defines a generation? My son and I were conversing today, as we often do, about "pop music." The question was whether or not older pop singers need to update their repertoire to attract younger listeners. It was a good, rollicking conversation. Most people enjoy music of one sort or another. And we love the fact that people love music. Watch American Idol or Singapore Idol to hear all the people who enjoy singing in the shower. Now, according to the great jazz musician, Duke Ellington, if music "sounds good it is good." All music is popular to someone, even church hymns. So there should be no argument about styles of music. One could certainly argue about the appropriateness of any one style of music for particular social settings. Normally you would not sing a funeral song at a wedding, nor a party song at a funeral service. I myself enjoy listening to a range of music, from what might be defined broadly as "classical music" to folk, blues, ...